The credit is nonrefundable. That may sound too good to be true. But, for most donors it isn’t, and for the rest, a five-year carryforward means the credit isn’t lost.
The Education Freedom Tax Credit (EFTC) is a nonrefundable tax credit. It can lower your federal income tax to zero, but it can’t turn into a refund on its own. If your credit is bigger than your tax in a given year, the unused amount carries forward for up to five years.
We covered the basics in what the Education Freedom Tax Credit is really worth. This article goes deeper on one question donors and their advisors keep asking: what happens if I don’t owe enough tax to use the whole credit?
First, the Basics
Give to a qualified Scholarship Granting Organization (SGO), like AFC Scholarship Fund, and receive a dollar-for-dollar federal tax credit: up to $1,700 for individuals, or up to $3,400 for married couples filing jointly. You give first; the credit reduces your federal tax bill when you file.
Giving opens January 1, 2027, and you claim the credit on your 2027 return. Below we cover what happens at that filing step.
Refundable vs. Nonrefundable Tax Credits
Tax credits come in two kinds.
- A refundable credit can pay you money even if you owe nothing. The Earned Income Tax Credit and the refundable part of the Child Tax Credit work this way.
- A nonrefundable credit can only reduce the tax you owe. Once your tax reaches zero, it stops.
The EFTC is nonrefundable. That makes sense for a credit tied to a charitable gift. It’s designed to offset the federal tax you’d otherwise pay, not to pay out cash.
But nonrefundable doesn’t mean use-it-or-lose-it. Unlike many nonrefundable credits, this one carries forward.
“Owe” Doesn’t Mean What You Pay in April
When we say the credit is limited by what you owe, we mean your total federal income tax for the year, not the balance due when you file.
Say your employer withholds tax from every paycheck, and you usually get a refund. You still owe federal income tax. Your withholding simply prepaid it. A nonrefundable credit lowers that total tax, so more of what you prepaid comes back to you.
In other words, getting a refund every spring doesn’t stop you from using the credit. What matters is your tax liability, the number on your return before withholding and payments are subtracted. If that number is $1,700 or more, an individual can use the full credit in the first year.
Other Credits Come First
Under Treasury’s proposed rules, the EFTC is applied after several other nonrefundable personal credits. Those include the Child Tax Credit, the Child and Dependent Care Credit, education credits like the American Opportunity and Lifetime Learning credits, the Saver’s Credit and a few others.
Be the First to Know
Get notified when the Education Freedom Tax Credit launches so you don’t miss the opportunity to support K–12 students while benefiting from a federal tax credit.
For most donors this changes nothing. It matters mainly if those other credits already bring your tax close to zero. A family with several children, for example, may find the Child Tax Credit covers much of its tax bill. Our comparison of the Child Tax Credit and the Education Freedom Tax Credit explains how the two differ.
How the Five-Year Carryforward Works
If your credit is more than your remaining tax for the year, you don’t lose the difference. It carries forward for up to five years.
Here’s a simple example. Let’s say a retired donor (we’ll call her Jane) gives $1,700 to a qualified SGO in 2027. Her federal income tax for 2027 is $1,000.
- On her 2027 return, she uses $1,000 of the credit, and her federal income tax drops to zero.
- The remaining $700 carries forward. She can use it on her 2028 return, or in any of the following years, up to five.
- Her gift was still fully used. The whole $1,700 went to scholarships the day she gave.
A few rules shape how this works under the proposed rules:
- Oldest credit first. Carried-forward credit is used before any new credit from the current year. Think of it as first in, first out.
- Carryforward can go above $1,700 in a single year. The $1,700 limit applies to each year’s new credit. A year’s carryforward plus new credit can together offset more than $1,700 of tax.
- No carryback. Unused credit moves forward, not back to earlier years.
- Five years is the limit. Credit not used within five years after the gift year expires.
Who Should Pay Attention to This
Most donors will use the full credit in the first year. The carryforward matters most if you:
- Are retired and live mostly on Social Security, savings or other income that’s lightly taxed.
- Have several children and claim a large Child Tax Credit.
- Have a low-income year, such as a career change, a sabbatical or a year with large business losses.
- Are part of a couple giving up to $3,400. A joint return needs enough combined tax to use the full credit. Our guide for married couples filing jointly covers how couples can plan their gifts.
If any of these sound like you, the carryforward is what makes the credit worth claiming anyway. You can give this year and use the credit over the next few years as your tax allows.
What About Giving More Than the Credit?
The credit covers up to $1,700 of an individual’s gift, or up to $3,400 for a married couple filing jointly. Give more, and you receive the same credit. The amount above it is treated like any other charitable contribution, subject to the usual tax rules.
One detail matters here. Credit you carry forward still counts as credit, so that portion can’t also be deducted. Only the part of your gift above the credit amount may be deductible. We explain how larger gifts work in the credit starts at $1,700, but your impact doesn’t stop there.
What to Do Before You Give
- Look at last year’s return. Find your total tax, not your refund or balance due. It’s the best quick estimate of whether you can use the full credit in one year.
- Ask your tax advisor about other credits. If you claim the Child Tax Credit or education credits, ask how much tax will be left for the Education Freedom Tax Credit.
- Keep your receipt. Keep the SGO’s written acknowledgment of your gift with your tax records. It helps you claim the credit and track any carryforward in later years. See the full donor timeline from gift to tax filing.
- Give anyway. Even if your tax is low this year, the carryforward gives your credit five more years to work.
No. It's nonrefundable. It can reduce your federal income tax to zero but can't create a refund on its own.
The unused amount carries forward for up to five years.
Yes, in most cases. The credit is limited by your total federal income tax, not the balance due when you file. If you have tax withheld, the credit can increase your refund.
No. Unused credit carries forward only.
Yes. The $1,700 limit applies to each year's new credit. Carried-forward credit plus new credit can together offset more than $1,700 in a single year.
No. Carried-forward credit can't also be deducted. Only the part of your gift above the credit amount may be deductible.