“Every K-12 child is eligible.” That’s the line school choice advocates use to describe the Education Freedom Tax Credit (EFTC). It’s true. It’s also incomplete, and for homeschool families, the missing half of that sentence matters more than almost anything else about this credit.
Eligibility to receive a scholarship and the ability to actually spend one are two different legal questions. Nearly every homeschooled child sails through the first. The second is where things get complicated, and where the honest answer right now is that nobody, including the U.S. Treasury Department, has entirely worked it out.
Two Questions, Not One
The credit itself is straightforward. A taxpayer contributes to a qualified Scholarship Granting Organization (SGO) and receives a dollar-for-dollar federal tax credit of up to $1,700, and the SGO uses that gift to fund a scholarship for an eligible student. The complication starts once you ask what that scholarship is actually allowed to pay for.
Almost any K-12 child clears the eligibility bar, which is why the roughly 90% of students qualify figure gets repeated so often. Homeschoolers pass this first test as easily as anyone.
The second question is narrower. A scholarship can only cover a qualified expense, and the law defines that by pointing to an older rule written for Coverdell education savings accounts. That rule ties every expense to a student’s enrollment in a “school,” and it leaves the definition of “school” to each state’s own law.
A homeschooled child can be fully eligible under the first test and still have nothing a scholarship is allowed to pay for, if the state they live in doesn’t legally call home instruction a “school.”
What Treasury Signaled
This isn’t a hypothetical reading of the statute. In its June 2026 rulemaking preview, Treasury suggested that this same cross-reference to Coverdell could mean exactly that: a student cannot receive a scholarship unless they attend a “school” as their state defines it, and a home school only counts if state law already treats it as one.
That single sentence turns a question of federal policy into dozens of separate questions of state law.
Be the First to Know
Get notified when the Education Freedom Tax Credit launches so you don’t miss the opportunity to support K–12 students while benefiting from a federal tax credit.
Why This Comes Down to State Law, Not Paperwork
It’s tempting to assume this tracks how much oversight a state puts on homeschoolers: testing requirements, portfolio reviews, notice filings. It doesn’t. A state can require almost nothing of homeschoolers and still legally define the home as a school, the way Texas has since a 1994 state supreme court ruling settled that homeschools are private schools under Texas law. Another state can regulate homeschooling closely and still keep it in a separate legal category that isn’t a “school” at all, routing home instruction through its own standalone statute rather than the private-school chapter of its education code.
At least 28 states currently fall on the side of that line where homeschools, and often the microschools, hybrid programs, and co-ops some families use instead, aren’t clearly defined as “schools.” That number isn’t fixed. States amend these statutes, and some families have a second legal pathway, like registering as a private or umbrella school, that could change their answer entirely.
What Would Actually Settle This
Two things could resolve it, and neither is on a guaranteed calendar. A state legislature could rewrite its homeschool law to define the home as a school, the way a number of states already do. Or Treasury’s forthcoming guidance on which expenses qualify, a separate rulemaking project that follows the main Section 25F rules, could address home education more directly. Until one of those happens, this remains an open question rather than a settled one.
What Homeschool Families Should Do Right Now
Treasury expects to issue its proposed regulations by the end of September 2026, in time for the credit’s January 2027 launch. Between now and then, families can find out how their own state’s homeschool law is actually written to guide decision-making once that guidance lands.
Homeschoolers clear the credit’s income-eligibility test as easily as any other K-12 student. The open question is narrower: whether a scholarship has anything it’s allowed to pay for, which depends on whether your state’s law defines home instruction as a “school.”
Yes. Because qualified expenses are defined by reference to Coverdell rules tied to “school” enrollment, and the law leaves that definition to each state, a homeschooled child’s practical eligibility to use a scholarship varies by state, not by federal rule.
Find out how your own state’s homeschool statute is actually written, not just how much oversight it requires. Treasury expects to issue proposed regulations by the end of September 2026, ahead of the credit’s January 2027 launch, and its answer on this question may resolve some of the uncertainty.
